Billion-dollar handout comes at a cost
Gov. DeWine has signed House Bill 96, the state’s biennial budget bill, after vetoing 67 line items from the text submitted last week by the General Assembly. Policy Matters Executive Director Hannah Halbert issued the following statement:
“As submitted to Gov. DeWine, this budget would have been devastating for Ohio’s families, schools, and communities. As signed by the governor, it is somewhat less destructive, but clearly a budget to meet the needs of the few at the expense of the majority. Ohioans deserve better than the least-bad option, but for the next two years, that’s what our elective officials have enacted.
“Ohio lawmakers have enacted a budget that will make teachers and truck drivers pay the same income tax rate as billionaires.
“We know — as do the lawmakers who voted to enact this budget — that Ohio’s wealthiest 20% of households will reap nearly all the benefits of a flat, 2.75% income tax. These households, with an income of at least $138,000, will receive over 96% of the $1.1 billion in annual income tax cuts.
“Lawmakers also know that the top 1% of Ohioans will receive close to 40% of the benefit, and an annual tax cut of over $6,500. That amount is pocket change for a cohort whose average annual income is $1.8 million. But at the cost of $428 million a year, that giveaway to the wealthiest 1% requires deep cuts to public services that benefit everyone.
“The federal government is poised to strip states of Medicaid and food assistance funding, putting thousands of Ohioans at risk. While Gov. DeWine used his veto pen to restore some flexibility to manage these unknowns, he failed to restore the most basic protection: Ohio’s income tax, the only tax based on the ability to pay.
“Ohioans are already paying the price for twenty years of income tax cuts for wealthy households. This budget will make things worse. More public school kids will lose teachers, and more parents will lose jobs because they can’t afford consistent childcare. Fewer young families will be able to buy a home. More Ohioans who use food banks will face empty shelves, and fewer Ohioans will get through college without mountains of debt. All of these are consequences of choices by Ohio legislators to craft a revenue policy that extracts from the public good to support the wealthy few.
Over the coming months, Policy Matters will offer detailed analysis of this budget and any budget overrides taken on by the legislature. Below is a summary of significant choices made by the governor before signing the bill.
Many of the provisions DeWine vetoed show just how radical and ill-advised the General Assembly’s budget was when it reached his desk.
Cash balance carry-over for K-12 schools and nonsensical “property tax reform”
Gov. DeWine vetoed a provision that would have required county budget commissions to reduce rates on current school district expense levies in certain circumstances where a district’s carry-over balance is more than 40% of its general fund expenditures in the prior year. The governor highlighted that the line item was contrary to local control and would undermine efforts by school districts to manage their finances responsibly and follow best business practices. Similarly, Gov. DeWine vetoed a provision that would have allowed county budget commissions to overturn local levies, as well as changes to how the 20-mill floor is calculated, which would have further destabilized public education. Instead, the governor will convene a working group on property tax reform. The group would be well served by taking up a property tax circuit breaker.
Tuition vouchers for private schools with “truly held religious beliefs”
DeWine vetoed a line item that would have created a so-called Educational Savings Account program, giving state-funded vouchers to families to pay tuition and other expenses at non-chartered, nonpublic schools. Unlike schools in Ohio’s existing voucher programs, these schools have avoided regulation and oversight because of truly held religious beliefs. DeWine noted that because these schools “are not chartered by the state, they do not receive any state or federal funds.”
School district board of education members
Gov. DeWine retained Ohio’s tradition of non-partisan school board elections.
Controlling board budgetary flexibility
The governor’s veto removes language that would have limited the controlling board’s expenditure authority. This change would have made it harder for Ohio to allocate federal funds or respond quickly to unexpected or extraordinary public needs. The governor also made changes to transfers from the Health and Human Services Reserve Fund to the General Revenue Fund. This language would have further limited the total amount the OBM director may transfer with controlling board approval and restricted critical funding needed to ensure healthcare access for Ohioans relying on Medicaid for needed care.
Continuous Medicaid coverage for children
Gov. DeWine vetoed a repeal of a program that provides continuous Medicaid enrollment for children ages 0-3. This program is a federal waiver that is currently in process with the federal government and will improve health coverage for Ohio families. The governor noted: “Access to needed healthcare for babies and young children is critical to early childhood development, and continuous health insurance coverage will help ensure children receive preventative care, ongoing care for chronic conditions, and hospitalization or emergency care.”
Changes to the State Share of Instruction formula for higher education
DeWine vetoed three sections of the budget that created new set-asides or restrictions for public colleges and universities to receive funding through SSI, Ohio’s primary source of funding for public higher education. With proper debate, two could prove valuable in the future but were poorly defined in the budget passed by the General Assembly: Employment Outcomes and Accelerated College and Career Pathways Set-Aside. The third would have allowed committees in the Senate and House to restrict SSI funding based on compliance with Senate Bill 1; DeWine’s veto leaves that determination to the Ohio Department of Higher Education.
LGBTQ youth
Gov. DeWine partially vetoed a provision that would have restricted funding for youth homeless shelters that “promote or affirm social gender transition.” Citing definitions from Merriam-Webster’s Dictionary, the governor retained language that strips funding from shelters that promote such transition but allowed funding for those that affirm it without promoting it. It is a small change that nevertheless will mean more homeless youth may receive services. DeWine also vetoed a provision that would have placed “vague restrictions on public libraries in an effort to regulate the placement of certain material within a public general circulation library.” Despite these positive changes, the governor did not veto language that will codify harmful and inaccurate binary standards.
Gov DeWine also protected some wasteful, ineffective tax breaks, rubber-stamped last-minute changes to childcare policy that will harm providers and the families they serve, and vetoed a provision that would have allowed teenagers convicted as adults to serve time in facilities managed by the Dept. of Youth Services.
Tax loopholes and tax giveaways
Gov. DeWine protected data centers’ tax breaks and vetoed a sunset provision, keeping credits like the Film and Theater production tax credit and the Historic Building Rehabilitation tax credit on the books after 2027. Although he wisely allowed a cap on what retailers get for collecting the sales tax — saving the state $30 million over the biennium — he also retained special carve-out so car dealers aren’t affected.
Publicly funded childcare
The governor did not veto two last-minute provisions which were hastily added during conference committee, without public input. One provision reduces the payment rates for Type A family childcare homes to match the Type B rates — a significant decrease from previous rates aligning Type A homes with childcare centers. The second provision raises the hour thresholds designating the status of a child as hourly, part-time, or full-time. This shortchanges providers who have budgeted for greater payment rates from the state than they will receive due to this change. These two provisions are only in effect through the biennium but will have drastic impacts on an already strained sector.
Criminal Legal System
Gov. DeWine did not veto any language regarding changes to public records law R.C. 149.43. The language will make it far more difficult to discover to discover Brady violations, restricting remedies for people wrongfully convicted. Additional public records changes create and expand exemptions for records specific to trial preparation, investigatory and attorney work products. These new exemptions will make it harder to do postconviction work by keeping important records hidden until it’s too late to file a postconviction petition on time. Not vetoing this language perpetuates the already harmful reality of wrongful convictions Ohioans continue to face.
Lame duck is an opportunity for legislators to act on data centers (and more)