This piece originally appeared on Cleveland.com on September 14, 2025.
After passing President Trump’s signature budget legislation this summer, the bill’s proponents began a PR campaign to convince Americans not to believe their eyes.
Legislators who voted for the bill are shouting from the rooftops that they didn’t chose to cut Medicaid, jeopardize rural hospitals, and increase the national debt, all to pay for more tax cuts that primarily benefit the wealthiest households.
The story they tell about this “big beautiful bill” is so thin that it insults the intelligence of every Ohioan who hears it. The ugly truth is that they have signed off on the largest upward transfer of wealth in American history. To do so they rolled back decades of progress toward a healthier, more economically stable future.
If you are among the 1% of Ohio taxpayers with annual income over $754,000 — a group for whom the bill cut taxes by an average of $61,000 a year — this bill serves you well. But far too many regular Ohioans will have their modest gains eroded by higher healthcare premiums for Affordable Care Act Marketplace plans, which are expected to increase by an average of $804 for a year of coverage for eligible Ohioans starting in 2026.
In the bill’s decade-long shadow an estimated 438,000 Ohioans will become uninsured by 2034 because of the megabill and legislators’ choice to allow ACA enhanced premium tax credits to expire.
The bill will especially harm Ohioans who rely on or work at rural hospitals. When faced with that reality, the bill’s supporters point to a special fund set aside for a “Rural Health Transformation.” They’re hoping Ohioans won’t notice a few important facts:
They chose to reduce federal Medicaid spending in rural areas by $137 billion over the next decade, but they only set aside $50 billion to offset those cuts. KFF estimates that Ohio will lose $5.62 billion in Medicaid funding over 10 years, the 7th highest loss nationwide.
In the past, politicians who wanted to gut public services like Medicaid would use the national debt as an excuse. Many of those same politicians are scrambling to justify voting for a bill that the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office found will increase the national deficit by $3.4 trillion in the next decade.
These politicians forced the CBO to run the numbers again using some questionable accounting methods to camouflage their cowardice. One easy way to know when someone’s pushing these fudged numbers: They claim the law actually cuts the deficit. Ohioans can spot that whopper without using a calculator.
Debating the bill won’t change the fact that it is now law. Northeast Ohioans will be able to judge for ourselves whether it makes our region a better place to live, work, and raise a family.
But we shouldn’t judge too quickly: The bill was designed to delay many of the deepest cuts until after midterm elections. It’s a transparent attempt to avoid accountability for all the ways this bill will harm Ohioans.
We’ll need to remember this debate as the funds start drying up, programs wither, and services fade. When it becomes impossible to sustain the public goods we have created by pooling our resources, we’ll need to remember how politicians sold us on this bill: with a smile and a promise that it won’t hurt a bit.
As feds allege SNAP fraud, Ohio public employees step up