CORRECTION: Where indicated, this analysis was edited to correctly state that ADP reported decreases of 3,000 private-sector jobs in August 2025 and 29,000 in September 2025.
The government reopened November 12 after a 43-day shutdown — the longest on record. National data from September was released yesterday, though the Office of Communications at ODJFS speculated that state-level data will not be released until mid-December.
In a statement accompanying yesterday’s September jobs report, the Bureau of Labor Statistics explained that data from the October Establishment survey would be included with the November data release, but that October Household survey data was not collected due to the lapse in appropriations. This means that we won’t have a complete understanding of how many workers in Ohio and across the U.S. were affected by the shutdown or other economic forces. October Establishment survey data, November Establishment survey data, and November Household survey data will be released December 16th.
Historically, the BLS and other federal statistical agencies have represented the gold standard for data integrity. Disparities between BLS and private-sector data are not an indication that that has changed — different surveys regularly produce differing results. However, because recent efforts to politicize BLS raise genuine concerns about data integrity, we will continue to monitor discrepancies between federal and private-sector data; in this analysis we use data from ADP.
The numbers: According to the BLS jobs report for September, U.S. employers added 119,000 total jobs in the private and public sectors. September’s growth followed minor losses in August (-4,000). The public sector added 22,000 jobs in September, entirely offsetting August’s public-sector losses (-22,000).
Downward revisions to national private-sector jobs data produced by the BLS for August also show weak job growth (+18,000), while ADP estimates that employers shed 3,000 2,900 jobs that month. According to the September jobs report released by the BLS, private-sector employers added 97,000 jobs nationwide between August and September 2025, while the ADP report shows a 29,000 27,000 decrease in private-sector employment over the same period. Despite disparities between BLS and ADP estimates for private sector employment for the second consecutive month – with BLS reporting job gains while ADP reports mild-to-moderate losses – we can’t identify a larger trend based on two months of data. Several more months are needed to determine if the divergence is a blip or a far more concerning trend.
The figure below shows the 3-month moving average of month-to-month change in private sector employment estimated by ADP and the BLS. Comparisons between BLS and ADP estimates for monthly employment change demonstrate alignment between longer-term trends, despite acute discrepancies in monthly data points.
Figure 1
“Private sector data sources diverge from the September BLS jobs report, making it difficult to say anything definitive about how the economy has fared recently.” said Heather Smith, researcher with Policy Matters Ohio. “Assessing the damage from the government shutdown will take several months of data.”
The household survey: National household survey data from September showed the number of unemployed people increased by 219,000. At the same time, the labor force increased by 470,000 and the number of employed people by 251,000. The national unemployment rate ticked up 0.1 percentage-points, from 4.3% in August to 4.4% in September.
Growth in unemployment nationwide has concerning implications for Ohio: While still relatively low, Ohio’s unemployment rate is one of the highest in the country and it has been on the rise. Ohio unemployment has been slowly but steadily increasing since April of 2023 (3.4%). Beginning in January of 2025, Ohio became one of the top 10 states for unemployment, ranking 9th in January (at 4.6%, compared to the U.S. rate of 4.0%). In recent months, Ohio maintained the 5th-highest unemployment rate in the U.S. from June (4.9%) through August (5.0%) of 2025, while the U.S. rate increased from 4.0% to 4.3% over the same period. The figure below shows how the gap has widened.
Figure 2
“It’s important to note that much of the growth in Ohio’s unemployment can be attributed to significant influxes of Ohioans entering the labor force,” Bryden said. “However, recent decreases in consumer spending, coupled with weakening consumer confidence and small business optimism, may signal economic contractions that could exacerbate barriers to good jobs. Upcoming data releases are critical for understanding how jobseekers are faring in the evolving economic landscape,” said Bryden.
What we know now: Ohio unemployment claims data showed initial claims ticking down after four consecutive weeks of increases, correlating with the beginning and end of the government shutdown. Despite the decrease, initial (5,961) and continued (42,161) claims for the week of November 9 – 15 are above the 8-week averages (5,461; 41,135).
“One thing we can say for certain: Hundreds of thousands of federal workers across the country were left unemployed for 43 days. The end of the shutdown is good news for them, and the thousands of Ohioans left without food assistance for the last 6 weeks – but bad news for the many Ohioans who will face increased health insurance premiums because of the bill that brought the shutdown to an end,” said Smith.
“The shutdown disrupted SNAP benefits and HeadStart programming, and threatened states’ utility bill assistance programs. Though delays in BLS data releases have obscured a comprehensive picture of statewide and national economic conditions, we don’t need these data to know that Ohio’s working families are hurting,” Bryden said.
Lame duck is an opportunity for legislators to act on data centers (and more)