House follows DeWine’s lead on tuition vouchers
Ohio’s top politicians want to spend an additional $432 million on private school tuition over the next two years, including a new voucher for unregulated religious schools. The House budget proposal, following the direction set by Gov. DeWine’s budget, continues to draw from a voucher playbook that disrupts and diminishes Ohio’s public schools, threatening the vast majority of Ohio children whose families rely on public schools to build their futures.
In his executive budget proposal, Gov. DeWine raised voucher spending by $375.9 million over the current two-year budget period,[1] from just over $2 billion to $2.4 billion. These new funds would go to Ohio’s five voucher programs: Cleveland, EdChoice, EdChoice Expansion, Autism, and Jon Peterson Special Education. The House budget includes this additional public funding for private school tuition.[2]
In the 2023-24 school year, Ohio gave out nearly 69,000 new EdChoice Expansion vouchers, while private school enrollment grew by just 3,700 students.[3] This means approximately 65,000 vouchers went to families already sending their children to private schools.
That same year, EdChoice Expansion recipients were wealthier than in previous years: Only 17% of 2023-24 recipients qualified as low-income, compared to 67% the previous year.[4]
Spending on Ohio’s voucher programs by school and fiscal year (in millions)
| Fiscal year | FY 22-23 budget | FY 24-25 budget | FY 26-27 budget | |||
| School year | 21-22 | 22-23 | 23-24 | 24-25 | 25-26 | 26-27 |
| Current voucher programs | $554.5 | $610.2 | $963.8 | $1,074 | - | - |
| DeWine proposal | – | - | - | - | $1,163 | $1,251 |
Sources: Spending data from SY 21-22 to 23-24 retrieved on 4/7/25 from the Ohio Department of Education and Workforce Report Portal. SY 24-25 spending estimates and SY 25-26 and 26-27 proposals were retrieved on 4/7/25 from the Legislative Service Commission Comparison Document.
The House wants (even) more money for vouchers
Gov. DeWine’s boost for vouchers didn’t satisfy leaders of the House. Their version of the budget would create a new voucher that can be used by nonchartered, nonpublic schools, which the Ohio Department of Education and Workforce defines as schools that, “because of truly held religious beliefs, choose to not be chartered by the State of Ohio.”[5] These schools are not currently eligible to accept tuition subsidies from the state’s five existing voucher programs.[6]
The House also would provide additional increases to both the Autism and Peterson voucher programs, and expand eligibility for the Peterson voucher.
House proposes voucher spending above Gov. DeWine’s budget (in millions)
| FY 26 | FY 27 | Totals | |
| Nonchartered voucher (“ESA”) | – | $35.1 | $35.1 |
| Autism voucher | $7.7 | $8.3 | $16.0 |
| Peterson voucher | $2.7 | $2.9 | $5.6 |
| Totals | $10.4 | $46.3 | $56.7 |
Source: Ohio Legislative Service Commission Comparison Document, retrieved on 4/7/25.
New voucher for nonchartered religious schools
The House calls their proposal a “nonchartered educational savings account (ESA) program,” but it would spend public money in the same way that the state’s voucher programs do. Ohio’s nonchartered nonpublic schools have avoided all but the most minimal reporting requirements and have entirely escaped regulation and accountability; the proposal would impose only minimal new rules.[7]
The new voucher in the House budget bill would:
- Prohibit families from using both it and one of the other state voucher programs at the same time.
- Cap the voucher at 75% of the EdChoice amount, which would be $4,625 for K-8 and $6,306 for 9-12 under current law.
- Reduce amounts for families at or above 450% of the federal poverty level, with the wealthiest Ohioans eligible for at least 10% of the total, like the EdChoice Expansion voucher.
- Allow the voucher to be used for tuition and fees, textbooks, instructional materials and supplies, unlike the Cleveland, EdChoice and EdChoice Expansion vouchers, which can only be used to pay for private school tuition.[8]
- Fund the new program from the same School Foundation line item that funds public schools, charter schools and the five existing voucher programs.[9]
- Spend approximately $35.1 million in its first year, the 2026-27 school year.[10]
The House budget’s language would eliminate Ohio’s nonchartered nonpublic tuition tax credit, in place since 2021, which provides a personal income tax credit of up to $1,500 depending on family income.[11] It would not eliminate the state’s credit for donations to voucher-granting organizations.[12]
Separate from the budget bill, Senate Bill 68, introduced by State Sen. Mark Romanchuk in February, would establish a similar voucher for nonchartered nonpublic schools for the 2026-27 school year (FY27). Rather than basing the new voucher on a percentage of the EdChoice voucher as the House does in its budget proposal, Romanchuk’s would pay private school tuition up to 90% of the statewide average base cost per pupil of $8,242 in FY25.[13] Like the budget bill’s new voucher, SB 68 would also allow private school families to use it for expenses above private school tuition. The Legislative Service Commission estimates this bill would cost $51 million in its first year.[14]
Extra increases for autism and special education vouchers
The House budget would increase the money available for the Autism voucher, for a total increase of $16 million in the coming biennium compared to the previous biennium. This voucher is for children with autism to attend a special education program other than the one operated by the school district of residence. There were no provisions in Gov. DeWine’s budget proposal for this expansion. The additional funding would cover a proposed new funding cap of $34,000, up from $32,445 currently.[15]
The House also proposes more money for the Peterson voucher – $2.7 million in FY26 and $2.9 million in FY27 – for a two-year total of $5.6 million; Gov. DeWine’s proposal included no such provisions. The extra funding would cover eligibility for three- and four-year-olds and increase maximum amounts for the six categories in the voucher; like the Autism voucher, the new funding cap would be $34,000, up from $32,445.[16] These vouchers are for students with a disability for whom an individualized education plan has been developed, generally by their school district of residence.
Families with children who qualify for special education services under federal law give up their rights to a free, appropriate public education when they send their children to private schools, which, unlike public schools, are not required to provide any special services for students who need them. [17]
Conclusion
Since the legislature made the EdChoice Expansion voucher universal, effective for the 2023-24 school year, participation in that program has more than quadrupled, from just over 23,000 in 2022-23, to an estimated 100,000 and climbing.[18]
The push by Gov. DeWine and the legislature to expand and increase subsidies for private school tuition over the next two years will continue to weaken the public schools the vast majority of Ohio families rely on.
The House versions’ increases to the Autism and Peterson vouchers, while small in comparison to Gov. DeWine’s proposed increases, will erode and disrupt public education by providing unregulated schools and non-school providers access to an increasing amount of public funds, primarily benefiting wealthier Ohio families, with no accountability to the public.
Creating yet another voucher program, for religious schools that have actively avoided public oversight and regulation, reveals the absolute disregard for the Ohio Constitution’s requirement for a system of common schools and flies in the face of our nation’s foundational belief in the separation of church and state.
If these measures are adopted, the result will be the further diminishment of our state’s education system, leaving the families who need it most – especially in Ohio’s urban and rural communities – with fewer resources and less support to secure a strong future for their children.
[1] Gov. DeWine’s budget proposal, HB 96 from the 136th Ohio General Assembly. Voucher spending increase of $375.9 million derived by subtracting total spending for the FY24/25 budget from the total proposed for FY26/27.
[3] Ohio Department of Education and Workforce (ODEW) Enrollment Data.
[4] ODEW, Nonpublic Data Portal, Scholarship Paid Participants (State), retrieved February 2025.
[5] Definition found on 4.7.25 at ODEW Nonchartered Nonpublic Schools.
[6] The 2024-25 list of nonchartered nonpublic schools is available on the ODEW website.
[7] See ODEW Nonchartered Nonpublic Schools and HB 96 online.
[8] Information about all Ohio voucher programs is on the ODEW website.
[9] General Revenue Fund, Appropriation Line Item 200550, Foundation Funding – All Students.
[10] Figure estimated in the Ohio Legislative Service Commission (LSC) Comparison Document for the Department of Education and Workforce, retrieved 4.7.25.
[11] See lines 126325 through 126327 of HB 96 online.
[12] The donation tax credit remains in HB 96, lines 126322 through 126325. For information on the credit for home instruction expenses, see Ohio Revised Code Section 5747.72 and the national edCHOICE website for Ohio.
[13] ODEW, Office of Budget and School Funding, Detailed School Funding Payment Report (SFPR) – Traditional School District, April #1 Payment, data as of 3.25.25
[14] Ohio Legislature page for Senate Bill 68, including Ohio Legislative Service Commission analysis.
[15] LSC Comparison Document for the Department of Education and Workforce.
[16] LSC Comparison Document for the Department of Education and Workforce. Under current law, children must be in kindergarten to use the Peterson voucher.
[17]In the event that a school district places a child with a disability in a private school because they can’t meet the child’s needs, that district must ensure the child receives the required services. Legal Aid Society of Cleveland, ”Special Education Rights in Public and Private Schools,“ 12.16.22. More on federal law: Section 504, the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act and Individualized Education Programs.
[18] ODEW Report Portal, retrieved 4.7.25.