Comment to the Ohio EPA on standards for PFAS

Reddit
LinkedIn
Facebook
X
Threads
Email

hank you for the opportunity to comment on Ohio EPA’s proposed rule establishing drinking water maximum contaminant levels (MCLs) for six PFAS. It’s a great start, but we believe the agency can do more.

As background, we are concerned about Intel Corporation’s construction of one of the world’s largest semiconductor wafer fabrication plants in New Albany. We are glad to see Intel locate here, but we believe more has to be done to ensure that the factory not add to the environmental load of PFAS on the environment, and in turn, threaten public health. The regulatory framework for PFAS in Ohio must take this major, new and continuing source of PFAS pollution into account.

Environmental review documents from Intel’s expansion in Chandler, Arizona, make it clear that the company plans to use a wide variety of PFAS compounds in production. Like other semiconductor companies, it considers those applications essential to advanced integrated circuit production.[1]

While the proposed MCLs properly address legacy PFAS contamination from chemical production and fire-fighting foam, given the length of time it takes to promulgate such rules, Ohio should be looking ahead to regulating the forms of PFAS likely to be used at the New Albany plant. The semiconductor industry stopped using PFOS years ago, and it has nearly finished its phase-out of PFOA.[2]

We recommend that Ohio start looking at PFAS compounds used by the semiconductor industry, beyond the six currently addressed by the proposed rule. Given the industry’s lack of transparency, as processes are shielded as confidential business information, wastewater sampling appears to be the public’s best source of information about PFAS in chip production.

The Vermont Department of Environmental Conservation originally required the GlobalFoundries plant in Essex Junction to sample its wastewater for five PFAS compounds, four of which are covered by the proposed Ohio MCL rule. When it expanded the analyte list to match U.S. EPA’s Method 1633, it found that concentrations of five other PFAS exceed concentrations of the original five in the Essex Junction effluent.[3]

We recommend that Ohio EPA begin work to develop drinking water standards for the other compounds likely to be used by Intel in New Albany.

One of the PFAS found most in chipmaking effluent is PFBS.[4] Industry switched from long-chain PFAS to PFBS in the belief that it was an “insignificant hazard.”[5] On the one hand, we are pleased that Ohio EPA is proposing a direct MCL for PFBS, while U.S. EPA did not. On the other hand, we believe that the 2,000 parts per trillion (ppt) threshold is not significantly protective. The scientific assessment of PFBS (and other PFAS) is evolving, so we suggest that Ohio review what drinking water thresholds are being recommended for PFBS elsewhere. For example, the state of Minnesota is recommending a PFBS Guidance Value of 0.1 parts per billion (100 ppt).[6]

Given the likelihood that Intel will be using and discharging significant amounts of PFBS in New Albany, we recommend that Ohio adopt an MCL based upon the findings of states that are more protective.

Finally, though it is beyond the scope of this specific rule, we wish to point out that there appears to be no current regulation of PFAS in chipmaking wastewater. In the absence of such regulation, semiconductor factories may continue to discharge PFAS to publicly owned treatment works, which in turn may discharge PFAS into surface water and/or release PFAS as biosolids. Preventing such releases would be more protective and efficient than treating drinking water impacted by wastewater discharges.

Given the establishment of a massive semiconductor plant in our state, we recommend that Ohio EPA develop policies to require the industrial pre-treatment of PFAS wastes at chipmaking factories, with an emphasis on emerging technologies that remove and destroy PFAS on site, without creating products of incomplete combustion or other transformation products.

Again, we appreciate the state’s efforts to protect the public and environment from PFAS. We urge you to look ahead to control the pollution from semiconductor production before it happens.


[1] “The Impact of a Potential PFAS Restriction on the Semiconductor Sector,” published by the Semiconductor Industry Association [SIA] PFAS Consortium, April 2023, https://www.semiconductors.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/Impact-of-a-Potential-PFAS-Restriction-on-the-Semiconductor-Sector-04_14_2023.pdf and “Draft Environmental Assessment for Intel Ocotillo,” U.S. Department of Commerce, NIST-CPO/EA-003, July 8, 2024, https://www.nist.gov/system/files/documents/2024/07/08/Intel%20Ocotillo%20EA_DRAFT%20FINAL_VOLUME%201%208July2024.pdf

[2] “PFOS and PFOA Conversion to Short-Chain PFAS-Containing Materials Used in Semiconductor Manufacturing,” prepared by the Semiconductor PFAS Consortium Photolithography Working Group, June 5, 2023

[3] Lenny Siegel, “PFAS Discharges from a Typical Semiconductor Plant GlobalFoundries, Essex Junction, Vermont,” August 23, 2024, http://www.cpeo.org/pubs/GFVTPFAS.pdf

[4] Paige Jacob, Kristas Barzen-Hanson, and Damian Helbling, “Target and Nontarget Analysis of Per- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances in Wastewater from Electronics Fabrication Facilities,” Environmental Science & Technology, February 16, 2021, p. 2353, at https://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/acs.est.0c06690. This study was sponsored by the semiconductor industry.

[5] “PFOS and PFOA Conversion to Short-Chain PFAS-Containing Materials Used in Semiconductor Manufacturing,” p. 6.

[6] “PFBS and Drinking Water,” Minnesota Department of Health, https://www.health.state.mn.us/communities/environment/risk/docs/guidance/gw/pfbsinfo.pdf

More Research

Get updates to your inbox.