Pay to stay in Ohio’s youth justice system

State requires parents and families to pay costs of confinement

Ohio families of justice-involved children face the strain of both family separation and financial penalties that deepen racial and economic disparities and perpetuate cycles of poverty. Of the many counterproductive and unfair financial sanctions used by the justice system, youth “pay-to-stay” fees, which require youth and families to pay for their stays in detention or placement, are among the most egregious.

This report highlights Ohio’s state and county pay-to-stay policies including analysis of county records regarding such practices and the harm done to Ohio families by requiring them to pay for their children’s incarceration. Legislators should abolish the practice throughout the state.

Cost of confinement law and practice

Ohio charges youth and their families for costs of their “care” while in juvenile correctional facilities.[1] Ohio statutes specifically allow courts to order youth to pay for their room and board and medical and dental treatment while in facilities.[2] Further, courts must order that parents pay for the care, support, maintenance, education, and medical care of their children committed to facilities.[3]  

These punitive policies may impact hundreds of children per year. In the past 16 years, juvenile courts in Ohio have committed young people to Department of Youth Services (DYS) facilities 8,109 times.[4] These include “juvenile correctional facilities,” which resemble prisons, and “alternative placements” which are smaller units that give confined youth somewhat more freedom of movement, but in which they are still held under lock and key.

There is limited public data available about how much money courts and counties are charging and collecting from parents when their children are in detention or placement. Juvenile Law Center, in collaboration with Policy Matters Ohio, sent public records requests to DYS and every county in Ohio to learn more about the practice. About half of the counties failed to respond; the responses we did receive highlight the prevalence of pay-to-stay fees throughout Ohio.

Between January 2018 and July 2024, DYS, which oversees Ohio’s youth correctional facilities, reported receiving over $346,000 in child support[5] from county child support agencies. Additionally, the following counties reported collecting and charging child support or other fees for youth placement and/or detention.[6]

  • Ashland: Courts order child support and use a child support worksheet to calculate how much money parents owe. The agency provides an example worksheet from 2020 in which the recommended amount of child support is over $400 a month.
  • Belmont: From 2018-21, the county collected about $2,400 in child support payments. The juvenile court orders payment of child support and the Belmont County Department of Child and Family Services calculates the amount of child support.
  • Butler: The county receives 40 cases per year for kids in DYS facility and the average child support order is about $50 a month. The county collects an average of about $10,700 per case with child support orders.
  • Clark: The county provided a list of 34 cases for which they charged child support.
  • Columbiana: Courts order child support and use a child support worksheet to calculate how much money parents owe. In the example order provided by the agency, the court ordered a young person’s parent to pay $550 a month to the court—the amount the parent received in social security benefits for the young person.
  • Defiance: Courts order child support and use a child support worksheet to calculate how much money parents owe. In the example worksheet provided by the agency, the recommended amount of child support was about $960 a month.
  • Holmes: County provided records of detention costs reimbursed by youths’ families. In 2023, the total amount reimbursed was around $4,500.
  • Lorain: County provided records of juvenile court journal entries ordering parents pay child support for confinement.
  • Preble: County provided sample child support orders.
  • Warren: County reported that there were 83 cases where child support was ordered from 2018-24. The county does not order child support for youth sent to DYS facilities but may order child support for youth sent to juvenile residential treatment facilities.

Several counties including Fulton, Gallia, Greene, Highland, Logan, Lucas, Madison, and Scioto, reported that they did not assess child support.

These county and state responses provide a snapshot of how pay-to-stay fees or child support are assessed around the state for incarcerated children. The data shows that youth and families can have significantly different experiences depending on the county in which they live, creating a “justice by geography” problem.

The impact

The financial costs of confining a child are likely to disproportionately impact families who can least afford to pay them. When families must pay even a small amount of costs, it results in families not having money for food, rent, or groceries.[7] Justice system costs can create financial strain between family members.[8]

Many justice-involved youth come from families with low incomes[9] and in Ohio, childhood poverty is troublingly common: 16.5% of all Ohio kids live in households with income below the Federal Poverty Level (FPL). [10] 

These economic disparities intersect with racial ones: In Ohio, Black youth and their families are impacted by poverty at even higher rates than the overall population. ACS data from 2024 shows that 1 in 4 Black Ohioans live in poverty, double the rate of their white counterparts.[11] More than a quarter of Ohio’s Black children live in families with incomes below the FPL — twice the rate of other children in Ohio.[12]  

Racial disparities and wage inequities create a perfect storm that hits Black mothers and caregivers especially hard. Nationally, 68.3%[13]of Black mothers bear the financial responsibility of their household — due in part to a criminal legal system that disproportionately harms Black men.[14] Although Black women in Ohio outpace the nation’s average as financial anchors of their households,[15] Ohio employers pay Black women less than any other race or gender group.[16] The racial wage gap[17] leads to and perpetuates child poverty, as Black women are more likely than their counterparts to be the sole or primary breadwinner for their families[18] and yet are most likely to be underpaid.

The result is a spiral of debt, through which Ohio siphons income away from Black families and communities and into the state’s youth justice system.[19]

Combined with legal costs and lost wages, the costs of confinement compound the financial harm done to justice-involved families. When involvement in the juvenile justice system is the result of poverty, financial support obligations only exacerbate the problem, undermining families’ pathways to stability. In at least one Ohio case, the parent of an imprisoned child was ordered to be imprisoned for failure to pay the cost of their child’s confinement.[20]

Public Defenders oppose pay-to-stay fees

Public Defenders have a unique perspective on the harm done to families when courts impose pay-to-stay fees on children. In a statement to Policy Matters Ohio, the Office of the Ohio Public Defender explicitly opposes “payment models that impose costs on children for time spent in detention or residential facilities.” Their full statement follows:

Most children involved in Ohio’s juvenile court system, and their families, cannot afford the cost of detention or residential placement associated with a delinquency case. Requiring children or their families to pay these costs can strain their financial stability, limit access to basic needs, and create long-term consequences that follow a child into adulthood, including barriers to pursuing higher education. These consequences may also increase the likelihood of reoffending and continued involvement in the justice system.

The U.S. Department of Justice[21] has recognized that “fines and fees can be particularly burdensome for youth, who may be unable to pay court-issued fines and fees themselves, burdening parents and guardians who may face untenable choices between paying court debts or paying for the entire family unit’s basic necessities, like food, clothing, and shelter.”

Similarly, in its 2025 report, the Juvenile Law Center in Pennsylvania found that court fees imposed on children were an “ineffective revenue source,” “do not support children becoming responsible and productive members of society,” and that “monetary sanctions increase youth recidivism and therefore undermine community safety.”

In Ohio, children in the juvenile justice system are presumed indigent pursuant to Ohio Administrative Code (OAC) 120-1-03(B)[22] and are constitutionally guaranteed the right to counsel regardless of their ability to pay. If a child or their family cannot afford an attorney, one must be appointed at the State’s expense. This presumption of indigency reflects the reality that children generally lack the financial means to pay for legal representation and, by extension, lack the ability to pay additional court-imposed costs or placement fees. The Supreme Court of Ohio[23] echoes this, directing juvenile courts to “presume that young people are unable to pay fines and fees and only impose them after an affirmative showing of ability to pay.”

For these reasons, the Office of the Ohio Public Defender (OPD) opposes payment models that impose costs on children for time spent in detention or residential facilities. Children generally lack the means to pay such fees, and courts should ensure that children and their families are not penalized based on their socioeconomic status. OPD supports the removal of facility-based fees and commends courts that prioritize rehabilitation and long-term success over financial penalties that can burden children well into adulthood. 

The solution

To support and strengthen families — especially those in communities disproportionately affected by poverty and youth incarceration — the state of Ohio must stop using financial penalties, including pay-to-stay fees.[24] There is a growing movement of states eliminating youth justice system costs, including pay-to-stay fees. Since 2019, 18 more states have made reforms removing some or all juvenile system fees and fines,[25] while Illinois and California have eliminated pay-to-stay costs.

Ohio should follow these examples by passing legislation to eliminate all youth pay-to-stay fees across the state.


[1] Debtors’ Prison for Kids? The High Cost of Fines and Fees in the Juvenile Justice System. Jessica Feierman et. al., 2016, Juvenile Law Center.

[2] Ohio Rev. Code Ann. § 2152.20: Authorized dispositions for delinquent child or juvenile traffic offender (A)(4)(b).

[3] Ohio Rev. Code Ann. § 2151.36: Support of child.

[4] Youth Services Admissions, Accessed April 2, 2026.

[5] Pay to stay fees are officially considered “child support” and can be paid to the same county agencies that manage child-support payments between parents. Ohio Rev. Code Ann. § 3119.01: Calculation of child support obligation definitions.

[6] Public records request responses from listed Ohio counties, sent to Juvenile Law Center, on file with the authors.

[7] Debtor’s Prison for Kids? The High Cost of Fines and Fees in the Juvenile Justice System by Jessica Fierman et. al., pg. 7, Juvenile Law Center.

[8] Impact of Juvenile Justice Fines and Fees on Family Life: Case Study in Dane County, WI by Leslie Paik, City College of the City University of New York and Chiara Packard, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Juvenile Law Center.

[9] An Evaluation of Ohio’s Behavioral Health Juvenile Justice (BHJJ) Initiative: A Closer Look at Success by Jeff Kretschmar et al, Begun Center for Violence Prevention Research and Education, February 2024.

[10] ACS Child Poverty in Ohio.

[11] S1703: Selected Characteristics of People at Specified Levels of Poverty in the Past 12 Months.

 American Community Survey 5-year Estimates 2019-2024. U.S. Census Bureau. Accessed May 5, 2026.

[12] S0201: ACS 1-Year Estimates Selected Population Profiles. American Community Survey 1-year Estimates 2024. U.S. Census Bureau. Accessed May 5, 2026.

[13] See Fig. 5 in the 2019 update to the Center for American Progress’s report, “Breadwinning Mothers Continue to be the U.S. Norm,” by Sarah Jane Glynn.

[14] For details about how Ohio’s criminal legal system severely restricts many Black men’s ability to work in all but the lowest-paid occupations, see our 2018 report on “the cost of excluding Ohioans with a record from work,” from Policy Matters economist Michael Shields.

[15] Holding Up Half the Sky: Mothers as Workers, Primary Caregivers, & Breadwinners During COVID-19 by Elyse Shaw et. al., Institute for Women‘s Policy Research, May 2020. Table 1.

[16] Median pay data are from our 2023 State of Working Ohio report, from Michael Shields, Jazmine Amoako and Bryce Springfield.

[17] Lifetime Wage Gap Losses by State for Black Women, National Women‘s Law Center, February 2025.

[18] “Black women can thrive in Ohio” by Tanisha Pruitt, PhD, June 19, 2024, Policy Matters Ohio.

[19] NCAJ Fines and Fees Index Ohio. Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas Juvenile Division Annual Reports. Over each of the past ten years, Black children made up the majority of the Youth Secure Detention population in Cuyahoga County alone.

[20] Through a public records request, Juvenile Law Center obtained a record of a Columbiana County parent incarcerated for failure to pay their child’s costs of confinement. The record is in possession of the authors.

[21] U.S. Department of Justice, Office for Access to Justice, Fines & Fees 49 (2023)

[22] Ohio Administrative Code Rule 120-1-03 (B)(4).

[23]  Supreme Court of Ohio’s Bench Card on the Collection of Fines and Fees in Juvenile Courts, 2024, page 1, citation 7: U.S. Department of Justice, Advisory for Recipients of Financial Assistance from the U.S. Department of Justice on Levying Fines and Fees on Juveniles, 2017.

[24] Pay-to-Stay Legislative Guide: Key legislative components for policymakers and advocates seeking to undo the harmful practice of pay-to-stay fees in their jurisdiction by Campaign Zero.

[25] States That Have Repealed Youth Fees and Fines, Debt Free Justice, 2024.

More Research

Get updates to your inbox.