Provider taxes fund Ohio’s Medicaid program
Medicaid is publicly funded health insurance, paid for with a combination of federal and state funding. H.R. 1, the 2025 federal budget bill,[1] shifted more of the costs of Medicaid onto the states. As a result, Ohio’s Medicaid program could experience a shortfall of up to $7.33 billion in the next state budget. State legislators have options to avoid that shortfall, but they must act soon.
Context: Medicaid in Ohio
Medicaid provides health insurance to over 3 million Ohioans: more than 1 in 4 adults and children. Enrollees include adults working low-paid jobs, children,[2] pregnant people, older adults, people with disabilities,[3] students with special needs,[4] and children in foster/kinship care.[5] Ohio Medicaid also covers:
- 2 in 5 children under the age of 18
- 1 in 5 working-age adults, ages 19-64
- 1 in 10 older adults, ages 65+[6]
- 707,000 students, making up a considerable 43% of Ohio’s K-12 public school enrollment.[7]
- More than half of all births in Ohio.[8]
Medicaid came into existence when President Lyndon B. Johnson signed the Social Security Act of 1965 into law.[9]
The Affordable Care Act (ACA) launched Medicaid Expansion in 2010, which allows states to expand Medicaid access to nearly all adults with incomes up to 138% of the Federal Poverty Level (currently $22,025 for a single adult).[10] Ohio implemented Medicaid expansion in 2014.[11] Both federal and state regulations on Medicaid (including H.R. 1) often treat traditional Medicaid and Medicaid expansion differently.
Overall, some of H.R. 1’s most harmful provisions apply only to, or more strictly to, Medicaid expansion states like Ohio. This includes several provider tax provisions that will be discussed later in this report: the phase-down of the safe harbor limit for provider taxes and the restriction of state-directed payments to 100% of Medicare rates. Several H.R. 1 provisions that are expected to cause the largest Medicaid coverage losses (most significantly work requirements and increasing frequency of redeterminations to every 6 months) apply only to Medicaid expansion enrollees.[12]
States fund Medicaid in part by collecting special taxes from healthcare providers. These provider taxes are common: In 2025, every state except Alaska had at least one, and Ohio was among 41 states (including Washington D.C.) with three or more.[13]
“Provider” refers to 19 specific categories of healthcare providers. The most commonly taxed providers include hospitals, insurers, nursing homes, and long-term care facilities.[14] States impose taxes or fees on providers to collect revenue for the state’s Medicaid program and then use this provider tax revenue to “draw down” federal matching funds.
The amount of federal funds a state receives depends on the Federal Medical Assistance Percentage (FMAP). FMAP represents the share of Medicaid expenditures that is covered by federal funds (federal share).[15] For example, an FMAP of 70% means that federal funding will cover $0.70 cents of every dollar of Medicaid expenditures. The state covers the other 30% ($0.30).[16]
Together, the revenue from the state share and the federal share gives states financial flexibility to fund important programs such as supplemental payments for certain provider categories, coverage expansions, new eligibility groups, or long-term care services and supports.[17]
States have been using provider taxes to fund Medicaid since the 1980s. The federal government first issued regulations on how provider taxes could be used in 1991, with additional regulations added over time.[18]
Context: Key Players in Medicaid Regulations
State
- Ohio Department of Medicaid (ODM): Administers the program at the state level.
- Director Scott Partika leads ODM.
- The Ohio Governor, House, and Senate can write and pass legislation about funding and covered services for Ohio Medicaid.
Federal
- Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS): Makes and enforces rules for Medicaid at the federal level.
- Dr. Mehmet Oz is the CMS Administrator.
- CMS is within the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), headed by Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.
- CMS has the power to approve or deny waiver applications and other proposed plans from individual states’ departments of Medicaid.
- Congress appropriates federal funding for Medicaid and writes and passes federal laws to regulate the Medicaid program.
Ohio taxes four of the 19 provider types:
- Hospitals
- Health Insurance Corporations (HICs)/Managed Care Organizations (MCOs)[19]
- Nursing Facilities
- Intermediate Care Facilities for Individuals with Intellectual Disability (ICF-ID)[20]
H.R. 1 requires changes to two of these taxes: Ohio’s Hospital Franchise Fee[21] and MCO/HIC Franchise Fee.[22]
H.R. 1 also restricts state-directed payments (SDPs), another use of revenue from provider taxes. That restriction is explored in more detail later in this report.
To draw down federal funds, a provider tax must meet several CMS requirements. The tax must be broad-basedand uniform: To be broad-based, the tax must apply to all providers of a certain type (e.g., all hospitals), and to be uniform, the tax must charge the same rate to all providers of a given class.
Providers may recoup some of the cost of these taxes when the state reimburses them for Medicaid-covered services. However, CMS also prohibits hold harmless arrangements, which are direct or indirect guarantees that states will reimburse providers for their provider tax payments. CMS’s hold harmless prohibition does not apply as long as the tax revenues remain below a statutory limit, also known as the safe harbor limit.
Prior to H.R. 1, the safe harbor limit was 6% of net patient revenues. In other words, if the state collected 6% or less of a provider’s net patient revenues, the state could hold the provider harmless and guarantee their money back. [23]Since 1991, CMS has offered waivers to states that have provider taxes that don’t meet the broad-based and/or uniformity provisions. States seeking a waiver had to show that their tax was generally redistributive, which means that the state uses tax revenue from non-Medicaid providers or services to help fund Medicaid.[24] Ohio has a uniformity waiver for its MCO/HIC franchise fee, allowing Ohio to use non-uniform rates.[25]
Changes Under H.R. 1
H.R. 1, passed on July 4, 2025, makes several changes that limit states’ uses of provider taxes and state-directed payments.[26] These include:[27]
- Prohibiting states from enacting new provider taxes or increasing existing ones (effective July 4, 2025).[28]
- Phasing down the safe harbor limit, thereby limiting the allowable tax rate (beginning October 1, 2027). This provision affects Ohio’s hospital franchise fee.[29]
- Capping SDPs, thereby limiting how much money states can pay to Medicaid providers (affects new SDPs as of July 4, 2025, phase-down of existing SDPs begins January 1, 2028).[30]
- Changing the definition of “generally redistributive,” which means that states can no longer receive a waiver of the broad-based and uniformity requirements. States, like Ohio, with an existing waiver receive a transition period to come into compliance. This provision affects Ohio’s MCO/HIC franchise fee (compliance due July 1, 2027).[31]
CMS subsequently released preliminary guidance[32] later superseded by a final rule[33] that clarifies the timeline and specifics of H.R. 1’s changes to provider taxes. The dates cited above reflect the final rule, which changed several provisions and dates compared to the preliminary guidance.[34] CMS rulemaking, most recently a July rule on hold harmless arrangements,[35] has been trending toward going “beyond the statute” of H.R. 1, with stricter, more expansive restrictions than H.R. 1 as enacted.[36] Because the release of rules and guidance on H.R. 1’s provider tax provisions is continuing, it’s important to pay attention to the current status of rules to accurately keep up with likely impacts.
Context: Fiscal Years
In Ohio, State Fiscal Years (SFY) begin on July 1 and end on June 30. For example, SFY 2026 began on July 1, 2025 and ended on June 30, 2026. Federal Fiscal Years (FFY) begin on October 1 and end on September 30 of the following year. Some states use different SFYs than Ohio.
Under H.R. 1, Ohio’s MCO/HIC franchise fee is non-compliant with the uniformity provision, because Ohio taxes Medicaid member months and non-Medicaid member months at different rates.[37] In other words, Ohio charges MCOs/HICs one set of dollar amounts for every client insured under Medicaid for a given month and a different set of dollar amounts for every client insured on any health plan that isn’t Medicaid for a given month. Ohio must bring its MCO/HIC franchise fee into compliance by July 1, 2027.[38]
For more details on Medicaid provisions in H.R. 1 and their effective dates, see the Health Policy Institute of Ohio (HPIO’s) comprehensive policy brief, “Changes to Medicaid financing in Ohio.” Provider tax provisions are just one of many significant ways H.R. 1 is negatively impacting state budgets and access to critical social services like health care and nutritional assistance for Americans.[39]
State Budget Impacts in Ohio — MCO/HIC Franchise Fee
Among healthcare advocates, a common question is “What financial loss will Ohio face from H.R. 1?” The answer is complex and depends on which year is used as the baseline and the number of years over which the loss is calculated. According to Policy Matters Ohio’s calculations, Ohio’s Medicaid program could face a funding gap of up to $7.33 billion in the next state budget if state legislators do not act.
Several commonly cited loss estimates use annual losses or 10-year losses.[40] Because Ohio budgets cover two years, Policy Matters calculated losses across two-year spans (a biennium). In 2024-2025, Ohio raised $2.2 billion from its MCO/HIC franchise fee — not including federal matching dollars. The state expects to raise $1.75 billion from the fee in 2026-2027.[41]
If Ohio doesn’t bring its MCO/HIC franchise fee into compliance with the uniformity requirement and can no longer rely on that tax, Ohio’s revenue from the MCO/HIC franchise fee will drop to $0. Using the 2026-2027 biennium as the baseline, this amounts to a $1.75 billion loss in state share; using 2024-2025 as the baseline, this amounts to a $2.2 billion loss in state share.
As shown below, the Ohio legislature appropriated a lower amount of revenue for the MCO/HIC franchise fee (and other line items) in 2026-2027 compared to 2024-2025, because of anticipated Medicaid disenrollments — see sidebar for context.[42]
Context: Less Revenue Means Fewer People Accessing Healthcare
Ohio’s Medicaid program helps Ohioans lead healthier lives; enrollment in the program is a measure of its success.[43] However, some analyses of H.R. 1 present reduced enrollment as “cost savings.” For example, ODM’s February 2026 presentation outlined a savings of $40 million per SFY from H.R. 1’s work reporting requirements.
Cutting costs by disenrolling people from Medicaid means fewer Ohioans will have access to the healthcare they need.[44] Several provisions in H.R. 1 will have that effect, and their implementation dates spread out over years. Estimates range from 70,000[45] to 356,000[46] Ohioans losing coverage by the end of 2028, due to just two of the provisions in H.R. 1. Both the wide range of disenrollment estimates, and the long timeline over which disenrollments may occur, complicate estimates of revenue loss from the MCO/HIC franchise fee.
The analysis in this report takes Medicaid enrollment before H.R. 1’s enactment (or the first half of 2025) as its baseline and does not consider Medicaid coverage loss as a savings.
MCO/HIC franchise fee revenue is calculated based on monthly plan enrollment. Higher Medicaid enrollment results in higher revenue from the MCO/HIC franchise fee, and lower Medicaid enrollment results in lower revenue. Lower enrollment also results in lower Medicaid expenditures, because fewer people receive healthcare services through Medicaid. The Ohio legislature’s decreased MCO/HIC franchise fee revenue for 2026-2027 compared to 2024-2025 reflects anticipated lower enrollment and, by extension, less revenue.
Provider taxes are especially valuable because they allow states to draw down federal matching dollars.[47] The table below shows our calculations of federal share and total funding, based on ODM’s state share numbers.[48]
As shown above, if Ohio legislators allow the state’s MCO/HIC franchise fee to be eliminated, Ohio Medicaid wouldn’t just lose the revenue from that fee, but also the billions in federal funding that revenue would draw down — a total loss to the state budget of $7.33 billion, compared to the 2024-2025 biennium. (This assumes no reductions in Medicaid enrollment.)
State Budget Impacts — Hospital Franchise Fee
H.R. 1’s phase-down of the safe harbor limit affects Ohio’s hospital franchise fee. In June 2025, Governor DeWine and ODM acted quickly[49] and raised Ohio’s hospital franchise fee rate from 3.43% to 5.31%[50] of net patient revenues. The result was that when H.R. 1 was enacted, Ohio had a tax rate within the new legal limit but higher than its previous rate. H.R. 1 initially maintains the existing limit (6% of net patient revenues) but phases it down by 0.5 percentage points per year, beginning in October 2027 (FFY 2028). The phase-down will first impact Ohio’s hospital franchise fee in October 2028 (FFY 2029)[51] when the limit phases down to 5%.[52]
Because of this, compared to each year in the 2024-2025 biennium, Ohio’s hospital franchise fee tax rate will be higher from 2026 until at least FFY 2032. In 2032, the 3.5% safe harbor limit will bring Ohio back to approximately where it started in the 2024-2025 biennium.
Context: Calculating the Franchise Fee
Ohio and CMS calculate the franchise fee in two different ways: Ohio assesses its hospital franchise fee as a percentage of adjusted total facility costs, and CMS calculates the fee as a percentage of hospital net patient revenues when determining whether it falls within the safe harbor limit. This distinction is important to keep in mind when using state and federal sources to understand the franchise fee. Before July 2025, Ohio’s hospital franchise fee was approximately 4.5% of adjusted total facility costs — or 3.43% of hospital net patient revenues. Starting in July 2025, Ohio’s hospital franchise fee rose to 8% of adjusted total facility costs — or 5.31% of hospital net patient revenues. By SFY 2027, Ohio’s franchise fee will decrease and remain below CMS’s 6% safe harbor limit.[53]
The actual amount of revenue collected depends on both the tax rate and the amount of facility costs that Ohio hospitals charge, which depends partly on the number of Ohioans enrolled in Medicaid and other health insurance plans. ODM estimates an annual loss of $220 -$280 million starting in FFY 2029 (October 1, 2028), or a total revenue loss of approximately $1.2 billion through 2032.[54] Based on ODM’s numbers, HPIO calculates an estimated annual loss (state and federal shares combined) of $733 million to $933 million.[55] But between July 1, 2025 and September 30, 2028, the hospital franchise fee should result in a gain, not a loss. It’s possible that the increase to the hospital franchise fee may partially offset the losses from the MCO/HIC franchise fee, but exact calculations are unavailable.
State Budget Impacts in Ohio — State Directed Payments
State-directed payments (SDPs) are a mechanism through which states pay money to providers who serve high volumes or percentages of Medicaid-enrolled patients. With CMS approval, a state can direct its MCOs/HICs to enhance payment rates to specific provider types.[56] SDPs fund important program initiatives such as:
- Increasing Medicaid payment rates
- Payment and service delivery reforms
- Value-based care models
- Quality improvement initiatives
H.R. 1 makes two changes to SDPs: It caps how much SDPs can boost provider payments, using the Medicare payment rate as a ceiling, and it reduces existing SDPs’ amounts by 10 percentage points annually until they reach the new ceiling.[57]
Ohio has multiple SDPs for its hospitals,[58], and HPIO estimates that H.R. 1’s changes will result in $200 million in annual losses for Ohio healthcare providers.[59] CMS released a proposed rule on SDPs in May of 2026 that, if finalized, may make the losses more than three times worse.[60]
Other State Solutions
Post H.R. 1’s passage, Ohio is one of seven states that are now out of compliance with the uniformity requirement, including California, Illinois, Massachusetts, Michigan, New York, and West Virginia. All seven states are Medicaid expansion states, and all seven use provider taxes heavily — that is, all seven states have three or more provider taxes.[61]
These states are gradually passing legislative solutions to their provider tax problem, most notably the proposed structure of taxing insurers’ revenue from health insurance premiums. Below are what states in similar positions are proposing, at the time of publication.
California
California is in a unique position, because its citizens required a continuation of the MCO/HIC tax. California had an MCO/HIC tax set to expire on January 1, 2027. In the November 2024 election, voters passed Proposition 35, which established the Protect Access to Healthcare Fund (separate from the state’s General Fund) and required the state to continue taxing MCOs/HICs after January 1, 2027, using the structure set by the existing (non-uniform) MCO/HIC tax.[62] When H.R. 1 made the tax non-compliant, Proposition 35 was already in place, requiring the tax to continue in a similar manner.
Legislators in California passed S.B. 125 in June 2026,[63] setting a uniform rate of $8.85 per member per month for its MCO/HIC tax from calendar years 2027 through 2029, which should comply with both laws.[64] The new tax rate is expected to generate $2.3 billion annually,[65] a little over half of the $4.5 billion expected from their state’s old MCO/HIC tax in 2024-2025.[66] Critics of the legislation worry that if health insurers pass along the cost of the tax to their privately-insured clients, the average Californian enrolled in private health insurance could pay an additional $100 in premiums per year.[67] California’s SFY[68] 2026-2027 budget also includes a “fair share proposal,” requiring the Department of Finance to draft a bill that would charge a fee to businesses whose employees are enrolled in Medicaid, in order to recoup the state’s cost of insuring those individuals. It also would incentivize businesses to offer their employees health insurance.[69]
Meanwhile, another voter-led campaign is underway in California. SEIU-UHW, a major healthcare workers union in California, has proposed a billionaires’ tax to fill funding gaps left by H.R. 1.[70] If the tax were enacted, the state would charge a one-time 5% tax on total wealth to all billionaires who lived in California as of January 1, 2027.[71] The initiative has received enough signatures to appear as Proposition 40 on California’s November 2026 ballot.[72]
Illinois
In February of 2026, the Illinois House of Representatives introduced HB 5111 to bring their MCO/HIC provider tax into compliance. HB 5111 says that Illinois may set its provider assessment (MCO/HIC franchise fee) at either a percentage of premium revenue or on a per member per month basis.[73] The bill specifies that rates must be uniform and must not exceed CMS limits.[74] HB 5111 was re-referred to the Rules Committee in March of 2026.
There is not yet a fiscal note for HB 5111,[75] which means that information is not yet available on how much money a tax on premium revenue would raise, or whether it would be enough to offset losses from H.R. 1.[76] Illinois faces additional complications, in that it may be the only state with both hospital and MCO tax rates above the eventual 3.5% safe harbor limit created by H.R. 1.[77]
Massachusetts
In Massachusetts, provider taxes generate approximately $2.3 billion per year for the Medicaid program.[78] The Massachusetts Taxpayers Foundation estimates a loss of about $70 million in revenue to the General Fund if Massachusetts were to implement one uniform MCO tax rate. $70 million is the total raised by the MCO Assessment, so an adjustment to the tax rate seems to be equivalent to the elimination of the tax. [79]
The Massachusetts government has not yet proposed a solution to offset the losses from the MCO Assessment being out of compliance. However, Massachusetts has substantial sources of revenue. Passed in 2022, the Fair Share Amendment, which created a 4% surtax on annual income above $1 million, raised $2.4 billion in SFY 2024 and $3.0 billion in SFY 2025.[80] The fair share tax revenue might supplant the need for provider tax revenue.
Context: Innovation in Massachusetts
Notably, Massachusetts is making healthcare more affordable by reducing the harm caused when Congress allowed Health Insurance Marketplace enhanced premium tax credits to expire at the end of 2025. Massachusetts is increasing investment in its ConnectorCare program (its state health insurance marketplace) by $250 million, bringing its total to $600 million. This investment will ensure that customers enrolled in ConnectorCare and making below 400 percent of the FPL will see minimal or no premium increase, while also lowering other out-of-pocket costs, such as copays and deductibles.[81]
Ohio has no state-run health insurance marketplace or state-sponsored plan. State legislators should strongly consider creating one, to improve healthcare access for Ohioans who don’t qualify for, or can’t afford, existing health insurance plans.
Michigan
On October 7, 2025, Michigan’s governor signed HB 4968 into law, in an attempt to preserve their Insurance Provider Assessment (IPA), Michigan’s MCO/HIC tax. [82] The new law says that if CMS approves a waiver for the broad-based and uniformity requirements, Michigan should keep its tax structure the same, but that if CMS terminates its approval of the waiver, HHS must create a new IPA tax that is in compliance with federal law. [83]
The Michigan League for Public Policy says that the bill “allow[s] for greater administrative authority to adjust the Insurance Provider Assessment (IPA) without needing to go back to the legislature to have them produce a compliant assessment.”[84] In other words, HB 4968 will make it easier for Michigan’s Department of Health and Human Services to adjust IPA tax rates in the future, but it does not propose a specific solution to bring the IPA into compliance with the uniformity requirement.
New York
New York state implemented an MCO/HIC provider tax as part of its SFY[85] 2024-2025 state budget, signed into law in April of 2024.[86] New York taxes providers based on member months, using a tiered rate ranging from $1.50 per member month to $126 per member month depending on plan type.[87] In December of 2024, CMS granted New York a waiver of the broad-based and uniformity requirements effective January 1, 2025, along with a letter notifying the state that CMS intended to change the rules in the near future.[88] Because CMS approved New York’s waiver less than two years ago, the final rule for H.R. 1 gives New York until January 1, 2027 to bring its tax into compliance, effectively ending the tax 3 months earlier than New York had originally planned.[89] The MCO/HIC tax was set to raise a net revenue of $3.7 billion over 9 quarters,[90] and instead will end up raising $3.4 billion over 8 quarters.[91]
New York’s SFY 2026-27 budget (passed in May of 2026)[92] replaces the MCO/HIC tax with a flat tax of 0.35% on total premium revenue across all managed care plans, equal to the rate being paid by commercial plans under the current tax.[93] The tax on premium revenue is expected to raise $165 million in net revenue in its initial year and more in subsequent years as MCO premiums rise.[94] Annual revenue of $165 million amounts to a small fraction of the revenue from New York’s existing MCO/HIC tax. The Greater New York Hospital Association observed, “While the new MCO tax generates significantly less revenue than the current tax, it serves as an important placeholder for future budget negotiations. We believe that it would be very difficult to resurrect the MCO tax in the future if it were allowed to sunset in December.”[95]
West Virginia
In March 2026, West Virginia’s governor signed HB 5459 into law, altering West Virginia’s health care provider tax on managed care organizations. Essentially, HB 5459 changes West Virginia’s MCO/HIC franchise fee from a tiered member-month method to a gross premium assessment method. The new tax, beginning July 1, 2027, is 2.5% of each insurer’s “gross premiums,” calculated quarterly. All health plans, regardless of their Medicaid and non-Medicaid enrollments, are taxed uniformly, with three types of non-Medicaid plans exempted from the tax entirely.[96]
According to the fiscal note for HB 5459, “the bill would increase Medicaid State Share Fund collections by up to $4 million in FY2027 and up to $17 million in subsequent fiscal years.”[97] Further research is needed to determine the total dollar amount expected from the gross premium assessment method provider tax in West Virginia.
Raising Revenue for Ohio – Healthcare-Specific Solutions
Ohio will likely need to raise approximately $1 billion annually in state share for Medicaid from any configuration of state taxes, in order to receive the full amount of federal matching funds to replace the MCO/HIC franchise fee. Ohio has many options for raising that $1 billion per year, including the adoption of solutions from similar states. This section explains why certain solutions may or may not work for Ohio.
Ohio could adopt several of the state solutions described above. Foremost among them, the gross premium assessment method — as proposed by Illinois, New York, and West Virginia — is worth exploring. Premium assessments would allow Ohio to continue collecting revenue from MCOs/HICs and drawing down federal matching funds, while incentivizing insurers to keep commercial premium charges low.
California’s “fair share” proposal, to charge businesses whose employees are Medicaid-enrolled a fee, is also intriguing. More research is needed to determine which Ohio employers have high numbers of employees utilizing Medicaid, how much the state could tax them, and additional methods of incentivizing employers to offer affordable health insurance to their employees.
Taking its cue from Michigan,Ohio could look at its process for setting MCO/HIC rates and streamline any part of the process that may be time-consuming. But more importantly, Ohio should revise its MCO/HIC tax to bring it into compliance with the uniformity requirement.
At first glance, the most obvious solution is to modify the MCO/HIC franchise fee to bring it into compliance with the uniformity requirement, like California, Massachusetts, and New York. But on further scrutiny, one uniform tax rate would likely raise far less revenue than Ohio needs. Ohio’s current franchise fee rates and revenue are as follows:[98]
Of the $881 million in total MCO/HIC revenue, Medicaid member months brought in 99.23% of the revenue, and non-Medicaid member months brought in less than 1%.[99]
HR 1 prohibits increases in provider taxes but does allow states to modify existing provider taxes, to bring them into compliance.[100] Ohio could lower the Medicaid member months rate to match the non-Medicaid member months rate. A rough estimate shows that doing so would result in a loss of 96.2% of Medicaid member months revenue, bringing in just $33.7 million from Medicaid member months. In other words, the total revenue collected would decrease from $881 million to just $40 million.[101] This is not a good solution.
If Ohio is going to modify its MCO/HIC tax to bring it into compliance, Ohio legislators and ODM should seek permission from CMS to both raise the non-Medicaid member months rate and lower the Medicaid member months rate, so that revenue collection remains approximately equal to the appropriated SFY 2026 or 2027 numbers. These rate modifications must be done carefully, to avoid driving up health insurance premiums for non-Medicaid plans. Adopting the gross premium assessment method may be a better alternative.
Raising Revenue for Ohio – General Solutions
Revenue raised for Medicaid does not have to come from healthcare organizations specifically. Many types of revenue could be appropriated to fund Ohio’s Medicaid program.
Policy Matters Ohio proposes a three-prong solution to raising revenue for Ohio generally:
- Increase the income tax on wealthy Ohioans,
- Reinstate a corporate income tax,
- Eliminate the business income deduction to the state income tax, also known as the LLC loophole, and other unproductive special-interest tax breaks.
Because Ohio legislators moved the state to a “flat tax” starting with the 2026-2027 budget, millionaires in Ohio will pay the same 2.75% income tax rate as public school teachers, child care workers, firefighters or any Ohioan with income over $26,050. Ohio will forego approximately $486.2 million in fiscal year 2026 and $1.03 billion in fiscal year 2027 due to the flat tax.[102] Reinstating tax brackets with higher tax rates for wealthy Ohioans would restore needed revenue, which could be used to draw down federal matching funds for Medicaid. In 2025, Policy Matters proposed adding two new tax brackets, of 5.99% at $250,000 and 7.99% at $500,000, and these or similar proposals remain advisable.[103]
Ohio is one of six states without a tax on corporate profits. Policy Matters recommends that Ohio’s legislature reinstate a state-level corporate income tax that works in concert with the existing Commercial Activity Tax (CAT). While new analysis would need to be done on what such a tax would raise now, after recent changes in the CAT, we estimated early in 2025 that such a tax could generate roughly $2.1 billion in new tax revenue.[104]
“Tax expenditures” is the formal name for tax breaks. While some, like the earned income tax credit, play a useful role in making Ohio’s tax code fairer, tax expenditures also reduce revenue. Every dollar not collected because of a tax break is a dollar we can’t invest in public goods Ohioans rely on. Policy Matters recommends eliminating several tax expenditures and reducing others. The Business Income Deduction (also known as the LLC loophole) allows owners of many Ohio businesses to pay no taxes on the first $250,000 of business income and a 3% tax rate on business income above that.[105] Policy Matters recommends eliminating it, because it primarily benefits wealthy Ohioans and will cost the state an estimated $919 million in SFY 2027.[106] Eliminating new agreements allowing the data center sales tax exemption, which added up to more than $1.5 billion in foregone state revenue last year,[107] would allow Ohio to raise tens of millions of dollars in future biennia. Other tax expenditures among the 177 the state lists in its biennial report could also be trimmed.[108]
Conclusion
Though Ohio faces a considerable Medicaid funding shortfall of up to $7.33 billion per biennium, the good news is that Ohio legislators can take action to mitigate some of the losses. If, by July 1, 2027, Ohio either modifies its MCO/HIC franchise fee to bring it into compliance with HR 1 or raises revenue through a different source, the shortfall can be eliminated, and Medicaid can continue to be funded at 2024-2025 levels. H.R. 1 will cost many Ohio Medicaid enrollees their health care coverage. Adding a funding shortfall on top of coverage losses is likely to result in cuts to Medicaid services, such as eliminating coverage for certain service categories or cutting provider payment rates, which will further damage Ohioans’ ability to receive affordable healthcare. Protecting funding for Medicaid is critical, because Medicaid provides health insurance for more than a quarter of Ohio’s population.
[1] H.R. 1 has also been also called the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA), Public Law 119-21 and the “Working Families Tax Cut” (WFTC) law.
[2] “Ohio Medicaid Basics 2025,” Health Policy Institute of Ohio, February 2025.
[3] “Medicaid in Ohio by County,” The Center for Community Solutions, accessed June 10, 2026.
[4] “Ohio Medicaid School Program,” Ohio Department of Medicaid, accessed June 10, 2026.
[5] “Foster Care,” Ohio Department of Medicaid, accessed June 10, 2026.
[6] “Medicaid in Ohio by County,” The Center for Community Solutions, accessed June 10, 2026.
[7] “Healthy Students Profiles for 2023-2024 School Year,” Ohio Department of Education & Workforce, May 2025.
[8] Scott Partika, “Report on Pregnant Women, Infants, and Children State Fiscal Year 2025,” Ohio Department of Medicaid, December 31, 2025, page 5.
[9] “Program History and Prior Initiatives,” Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, accessed June 10, 2026.
[10] “2026 Poverty Guidelines: 48 Contiguous States (all states except Alaska and Hawaii),” U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of the Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation, accessed May 29, 2026.
[11] “Status of State Medicaid Expansion Decisions,” KFF, May 21, 2026.
[12] Edwin Park and Sabrina Corlette, “Medicaid, CHIP, and Affordable Care Act Marketplace Cuts and Other Health Provisions in the Budget Reconciliation Law, Explained,” Georgetown University McCourt School of Public Policy, Center for Families and Children, July 22, 2025.
[13] Alice Burns et. al., “5 Key Facts About Medicaid and Provider Taxes,” KFF, Dec 1, 2025.
[14] Alison Mitchell, “Medicaid Provider Taxes,” Library of Congress, December 30, 2024.
[15] Alison Mitchell, “Medicaid’s Federal Medical Assistance Percentage (FMAP),” Library of Congress, April 2, 2025.
[16] FMAP calculations are more complicated than a single, set percentage. Within each state, the FMAP varies by the type of Medicaid enrollment. In 2026, Ohio’s regular FMAP is 64.85%, enhanced FMAP (used for the Children’s Health Insurance Program, or CHIP) is 75.40%, and expansion FMAP is 90%. This analysis uses a 70% “blended” FMAP in alignment with Health Policy Institute of Ohio (HPIO) for estimating federal share without having to account for variables at each FMAP level.
Amy Rohling McGee, Brian O’Rourke, “Changes to Medicaid financing in Ohio,” Health Policy Institute of Ohio, March 2026.
Nelson V. Lindgren, “Greenbook LBO Analysis of Enacted Budget Ohio Department of Medicaid,” Legislative Service Commission,” July 2025, pages 6-7.
[17] Hannah Kim, “How Medicaid Provider Taxes Work: An Explainer,” National Association of Medicaid Directors, September 25, 2025.
[18] Alison Mitchell, “Medicaid Provider Taxes,” Library of Congress, December 30, 2024.
Congressional Research Service, “Summary: H.R.3595 — 102nd Congress (1991-1992),” Congress.gov, accessed June 17, 2026.
[19] Federal and state regulations use “HIC” and “MCO” interchangeably.
Amy Rohling McGee, Brian O’Rourke, “Changes to Medicaid financing in Ohio,” Health Policy Institute of Ohio, March 2026.
[20] Alison Mitchell, “Medicaid Provider Taxes,” Library of Congress, December 30, 2024.
“States Reporting Taxes by Provider Type, SFY 2025,” KFF, accessed May 20, 2026.
[21] For the purposes of this report, “franchise fee” is synonymous with “provider tax.”
“Ohio Hospital Franchise Fee,” Ohio Hospital Association, accessed May 20, 2026.
[22] “Section 5168.76 | Franchise fee on health insuring corporation plans,” Ohio Revised Code, Effective: June 29, 2017.
[23] Alice Burns et. al., “5 Key Facts About Medicaid and Provider Taxes,” KFF, Dec 1, 2025.
[24] Alison Mitchell, “Medicaid Provider Taxes,” Library of Congress, December 30, 2024.
Federal Register, Vol. 57, No. 227, November 24, 1992, page 55128.
[25] Amy Rohling McGee, Brian O’Rourke, “Changes to Medicaid financing in Ohio,” Health Policy Institute of Ohio, March 2026.
[26] “H.R.1 – An act to provide for reconciliation pursuant to title II of H. Con. Res. 14.,” Congress.gov, July 4, 2025, accessed June 8, 2026.
[27] “Medicaid Program; Preserving Medicaid Funding for Vulnerable Populations-Closing a Health Care-Related Tax Loophole,” Federal Register, February 2, 2026.
[28] Section 71115 of “H.R.1 – An act to provide for reconciliation pursuant to title II of H. Con. Res. 14.,” Congress.gov, July 4, 2025, accessed June 8, 2026.
[29] Ibid.
[30] Section 71116 of “H.R.1 – An act to provide for reconciliation pursuant to title II of H. Con. Res. 14.,” Congress.gov, July 4, 2025, accessed June 8, 2026.
[31] Section 71117 of “H.R.1 – An act to provide for reconciliation pursuant to title II of H. Con. Res. 14.,” Congress.gov, July 4, 2025, accessed June 8, 2026.
“Health Provisions in the 2025 Federal Budget Reconciliation Law,” KFF, August 22, 2025.
Edwin Park, “CMS Issues Final Rule Implementing H.R. 1’s Prohibition of Certain Uniformity Waiver Provider Taxes,” Georgetown University, McCourt School of Public Policy, Center for Children and Families, February 2, 2026.
[32] Dan Brillman, “SUBJECT: Section 71115 and 71117 of Working Families Tax Cuts Legislation on Provider Taxes,” Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, November 14, 2025.
[33] Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., “Medicaid Program; Preserving Medicaid Funding for Vulnerable Populations-Closing a Health Care-Related Tax Loophole,” Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, February 2, 2026.
[34] Ibid.
[35] Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., “Medicaid Program; Amending the Indirect Hold Harmless Threshold of Health Care-Related Taxes,” Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, July 23, 2026.
[36] Leonardo Cuello, “CMS Ignores the Law (Again) – This Time Taking Health Insurance Away from Individuals with Substance Use Disorders, Mental Health Conditions, and Serious Health Conditions,” Georgetown University, McCourt School of Public Policy, Center for Children and Families, June 18, 2026.
[37] Ohio taxes its Medicaid member months at tiered rates ranging from $26 to $56 per member per month. Ohio taxes its non-Medicaid member months at tiered rates ranging from $1 to $2 per member per month. Section 5168.76 | Franchise fee on health insuring corporation plans,” Ohio Revised Code, Effective: June 29, 2017.
[38] Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., “Medicaid Program; Preserving Medicaid Funding for Vulnerable Populations-Closing a Health Care-Related Tax Loophole,” Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, February 2, 2026.
[39] Kate Sopko, “Fallout from federal budget cuts will last years,” Policy Matters Ohio, November 13, 2025.
[40] For example, KFF estimates the 10-year federal funding loss to Ohio as $33 billion, or ranging from $24 billion to $41 billion. Rhiannon Euhus et. al, “Allocating CBO’s Estimates of Federal Medicaid Spending Reductions Across the States: Enacted Reconciliation Package,” KFF, July 23, 2025.
[41] Nelson V. Lindgren, “Greenbook LBO Analysis of Enacted Budget Ohio Department of Medicaid,” Legislative Service Commission,” July 2025, page 17.
[42] Ibid., pages 20-21.
[43] Kathryn Poe, “Testimony to the Senate Medicaid Committee on HB 96,” Policy Matters Ohio, May 13, 2025.
[44] Scott Partika, “H.R. 1 (OBBBA) Updates,” Ohio Department of Medicaid, February 19, 2026, page 12.
[45] Ibid.
[46] This estimate accounts for work requirements and six-month redeterminations. Matthew Buettgens et al., “Projected Reductions in Medicaid Expansion Enrollment Under OBBBA’s Work Requirements and Six-Month Redeterminations National and State Estimates for 2028,” Urban Institute, March 2026.
[47] This analysis uses a 70% “blended” FMAP for estimating federal share. See footnote 16 for more detail.
[48] A note on methodology for understanding different loss estimates: ODM estimates an annual loss of $640 million in state share, likely anticipating further disenrollments (see sidebar “Less Revenue Means Fewer People Accessing Healthcare”). That would amount to a loss of $1.28 billon in state share over the 2028-2029 biennium. (Scott Partika, “H.R. 1 (OBBBA) Updates,” Ohio Department of Medicaid, February 19, 2026, page 19.)
The Health Policy Institute of Ohio (HPIO)’s loss estimates use ODM’s estimate of a $640 million annual loss in state share and calculates a total annual loss (including federal matching funds) of $2.1 billion, which would be a loss of $4.2 over the biennium. (Amy Rohling McGee, Brian O’Rourke, “Changes to Medicaid financing in Ohio,” Health Policy Institute of Ohio, March 2026.)
This Policy Matters Ohio analysis looks at the question in a different way—we compare $0 of revenue in the 2028-2029 biennium to the appropriated revenue for the 2024-2025 biennium, before coverage losses. Using the same 70% blended FMAP as HPIO, Policy Matters calculates that the total expected MCO/HIC franchise fee revenue for the 2024-2025 biennium is $7.33 billion, and that all of that money would be lost in the 2028-2029 biennium if Ohio does not come into compliance with H.R. 1. The $7.33 billion figure does not take current or future Medicaid disenrollments into account. Disenrollments would decrease MCO/HIC franchise fee revenues regardless of changes to the rules surrounding provider taxes.
[49] “Rule 5160-2-30 | Hospital franchise fee program,” Ohio Revised Code, Effective: October 14, 2025. Please note that the prior effective date was June 16, 2025, as an emergency change.
Mike DeWine, “Executive Order 2025-02D,” Ohio Governor, June 16, 2025.
“Rule Summary and Fiscal Analysis, Rule Number: 5160-2-30,” Ohio Register of State, July 29, 2025.
[50] “Hospital Package,” Ohio Legislative Information Systems, accessed June 15, 2026.
[51] Amy Rohling McGee, Brian O’Rourke, “Changes to Medicaid financing in Ohio,” Health Policy Institute of Ohio, March 2026.
[52] Section 71115 of “H.R.1 – An act to provide for reconciliation pursuant to title II of H. Con. Res. 14.,” Congress.gov, July 4, 2025, accessed June 8, 2026.
[53] Amy Rohling McGee, Brian O’Rourke, “Changes to Medicaid financing in Ohio,” Health Policy Institute of Ohio, March 2026.
[54] Scott Partika, “H.R. 1 (OBBBA) Updates,” Ohio Department of Medicaid, February 19, 2026.
[55] Amy Rohling McGee, Brian O’Rourke, “Changes to Medicaid financing in Ohio,” Health Policy Institute of Ohio, March 2026.
[56] Anne Karl, Cindy Mann, Emily Polk, Jacob Rains, “How Medicaid State-Directed Payments Support Critical Health Care Providers,” The Commonwealth Fund, July 3, 2025.
[57] Amy Rohling McGee, Brian O’Rourke, “Changes to Medicaid financing in Ohio,” Health Policy Institute of Ohio, March 2026.
[58] “Approved State Directed Payment Preprints,” Center for Medicare & Medicaid Services, accessed June 12, 2026. Please note that this list includes both active and expired SDPs.
[59] Amy Rohling McGee, Brian O’Rourke, “Changes to Medicaid financing in Ohio,” Health Policy Institute of Ohio, March 2026.
[60] Madelaine Matej MacQueen. “Public comment on State Directed Payments and Medicaid Fee-for-Service Targeted Medicaid Practitioner Payments,” Policy Matters Ohio. July 22, 2026.
[61] Policy Matters Ohio analysis.
[62] “California Proposition 35, Managed Care Organization Tax Authorization Initiative (2024),” Ballotpedia, accessed July 2, 2026. See “CHAPTER 7.5. Protect Access to Healthcare Act of2024,” “Section 14199.123. Continued Imposition of Tax.”
[63] Senate Bill No. 125, California Legislative Information, June 26, 2026.
[64] Paul Jones, “California Lawmakers, Newsom Reach Final Budget Deal,” Tax Notes, July 1, 2026.
[65] Ana B. Ibarra, “California is getting ready to increase a health insurance tax. Will it affect your premium?” Cal Matters, June 18, 2026.
[66] Gabriela Villaneuva, “California Budget Revision: Where Healthcare Funding Stands,” Cooperative of American Physicians, June 2, 2026.
[67] Ana B. Ibarra, “California is getting ready to increase a health insurance tax. Will it affect your premium?” Cal Matters, June 18, 2026.
[68] California’s State Fiscal Year (SFY) runs from July 1 to June 30 of the following year. See “Fiscal and Financial,” California Department of Social Services, accessed July 2, 2026.
[69] Paul Jones, “California Lawmakers, Newsom Reach Final Budget Deal,” Tax Notes, July 1, 2026.
[70] Hamilton Nolan, “In California, It’s Either Tax the Billionaires or Face a Health Care “Catastrophe”,” How Things Work, April 17, 2026.
[71] Suzanne Jimenez, “The 2026 Billionaire Tax Act,” November 24, 2025.
[72] “California Proposition 40, One-Time Wealth Tax for State-Funded Healthcare, Education, and Food Assistance Programs Initiative (2026),” Ballotpedia, accessed July 23, 2026.
[73] “IL HB5111 | 2025-2026 | 104th General Assembly,” LegiScan, accessed May 6, 2026.
[74] “Bill Texts: IL HB5111 | 2025-2026 | 104th General Assembly,” LegiScan, accessed May 6, 2026.
[75] “HB5111 – 104th General Assembly, DHFS-MCO PROVIDER ASSESSMENT,” ILGA.GOV, accessed May 6, 2026.
[76] David Merriman and Paula Worthington, “Report Highlights Changes to Medical Provider Taxes Could Have Substantial Impact on Medicaid Funding,” University of Illinois System Institute of Government and Public Affairs, January 6, 2026.
Peter Hancock, “Illinois Medicaid program faces looming funding crisis due to federal changes,” Capitol News Illinois, January 19, 2026.
[77] Alea Wilbur-Mujtaba, David Merriman, Paula Worthington, Jahun Lee, and Xiaoyan Hu, “Current Condition and Future Concerns for Growth in Illinois’ State Revenue,” Institute of Government and Public Affairs, January 6, 2026.
[78] “2025 Health Care Cost Trends Hearing Recap,” Massachusetts Health Policy Commission, December 8, 2025.
[79] “MTF Bulletin,” Massachusetts Taxpayers Foundation, September 10, 2025.
[80] “Fair Share is delivering real results in education & transportation,” Massachusetts Executive Office for Administration and Finance., accessed May 20, 2026.
[81] “Governor Healey Details Strongest Plan in the Country to Protect Against President Trump’s ACA Cost Hikes,” Mass.gov, January 8, 2026.
[82] “Bill Text: MI HB4968 | 2025-2026 | 103rd Legislature | Chaptered,” LegiScan, accessed May 6, 2026.
[83] Jakob Emerson, “Michigan extends insurer tax to preserve Medicaid funding,” Becker’s Payer Issues, October 14th, 2025.
[84] Amber Bellazaire, Senior Policy Analyst, Michigan League for Public Policy, personal email correspondence with Madelaine Matej MacQueen, Budget Researcher, Policy Matters Ohio, February 26, 2026.
[85] New York’s State Fiscal Year (SFY) runs from April 1 to March 31 of the following year. For example, SFY 2026 runs April 1, 2025, to March 31, 2026. See “The Budget Process.”
[86] Gregory R. Mitchell, “New York State Budget Institutes Revenue-Neutral Health Plan Tax,” McDermott Will & Schulte, April 30, 2024. For exact language in the budget bill, please see “Health and Mental Hygiene (HMH) Bill (A8807-C/S8307-C),” New York assembly, page 64.
[87] “SECTION 2807-FF, New York managed care organization provider tax, Public Health (PBH) CHAPTER 45, ARTICLE 28,” New York State Senate, revised May 16, 2025.
Gregory R. Mitchell and Abygail Hoey, “New York Executive Budget Proposes Amendments to MCO Provider Tax,” McDermott Will & Schulte, February 12, 2025.
[88] Rory Howe, letter “Dear Deputy Commissioner Bassiri,” Financial Management Group, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, December 20, 2024.
[89] “Medicaid Program; Preserving Medicaid Funding for Vulnerable Populations-Closing a Health Care-Related Tax Loophole, A Rule by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services,” February 2, 2026.
[90] Kathy Hochul, “FY2026 NYS Enacted Budget Financial Plan,” New York State Division of the Budget, June 2025, page 11.
Thomas P. DiNapoli, “Report on the State Fiscal Year 2027 Executive Budget,” New York State Comptroller, February 2026, page 3 and 34.
[91] MCO tax net revenues are calculated by subtracting Assessment Offsets from Miscellaneous Receipts, in the line items of the Healthcare Stability Fund. Kathy Hochul, “FY 2027 NYS Enacted Budget Financial Plan,” New York State Division of the Budget, June 2026, page 109. Note that Assessment Offsets represent payments made back to MCOs. See Michael Kinnucan, “Strange Accounting: Understanding the Growth in New York’s Medicaid Spending,” Fiscal Policy Institute, February 15, 2025.
[92] “NYS Senate Majority Passes SFY 2026-27 Budget: Prioritizing Affordability, Defending New York Values, and Delivering for Families,” New York Senate, May 28, 2026.
[93] Kenneth E. Raske, “Member Letter Re: Final State Budget Includes Significant Investments to Help Stabilize New York’s Hospitals and Nursing Homes,” Greater New York Hospital Association, May 27, 2026. Accessed via a request to GNYHA.
[94] Ibid.
[95] Ibid.
[96] “ENROLLED House Bill 5459,” West Virginia Legislature, March 11, 2026.
[97] Peter Shirley, “Fiscal Note HB5459,” Tax & Revenue Department, WV State, accessed May 6, 2026.
[98] “JMOC Fee Report – ORC 5168.90,” Ohio Department of Medicaid, July 28, 2025.
[99] Ibid.
[100] “Medicaid Program; Preserving Medicaid Funding for Vulnerable Populations-Closing a Health Care-Related Tax Loophole, A Rule by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services,” February 2, 2026.
[101] Policy Matters Ohio analysis.
[102] Aditi Srivastava, “The Great Ohio Tax Shift, 2026,” Policy Matters Ohio, February 19, 2026.
[103] Bailey Williams, “Revise Ohio’s tax code to benefit everyday Ohioans,” February 2025, page 6.
[104] Ibid., page 7.
[105] Aditi Srivastava, “The Great Ohio Tax Shift, 2026,” Policy Matters Ohio, February 19, 2026.
[106] Patricia Harris, “Tax Expenditure Report / The State of Ohio Executive Budget / Fiscal Years 2026/2027,” Department of Taxation, November 1, 2024, page 16.
[107] Jake Zuckerman, “Ohio data center tax break cost $1.4 billion more than expected in 2025,” Signal Ohio, May 21, 2026.
Ohio could also follow the lead of Virginia, and require large data center operators to pay a tax in order to make up some of the costs of the exemption that are baked in as a result of existing contracts.
[108] Aditi Srivastava, “Spring cleaning for Ohio’s tax code,” Policy Matters Ohio, April 15, 2026.
Ben Stein, “Tax expenditures shortchange Ohioans,” Policy Matters Ohio, September 9, 2025.