Child care surveillance bills are cause for concern

by:
Reddit
LinkedIn
Facebook
X
Threads
Email

Child care families and providers need policy based on facts, not social media trends

Lawmakers in the Ohio House reacted to a wave of online misinformation[1] about “child care fraud” by introducing two misguided bills that will increase surveillance of children and child care providers, and give parents no mechanism for opting out. The bills raise serious concerns about privacy — allowing the state to collect and store videos of children and other sensitive data —and allow the state to cut funding for providers at will, without proof of wrongdoing.

Ohio already has strong systems in place to protect children and taxpayers. [2] Licensed child care providers follow more than 1,000 regulations and undergo routine, thorough, unannounced inspections every year. Those reports are available for anyone to review.

Instead of allowing social media-induced panic to dictate their policymaking, legislators should listen to parents, providers, and advocates who have long pushed for additional state funding[3] and commonsense, fact-based solutions.[4] They should focus on increasing access and lowering the cost of high-quality care. These proposals would do neither, and would deepen Ohio’s ongoing child care crisis.

HB 649 mandates state surveillance of Ohio children, including unsecured live footage,[5] adds bureaucracy, and destabilizes a sector already in crisis.

Sponsored by: Rep. Josh Williams (R‑Sylvania Twp.) and Rep. D.J. Swearingen (R‑Sandusky), supported by Attorney General Dave Yost

Key provisions

  • Mandatory cameras inside and outside all licensed child care centers, covering all non‑private classroom spaces (at the expense of the child care provider).
  • No option for parents to opt-out of having their children recorded.
  • Requires providers to allow the Department of Children and Youth (DCY) access to real‑time, live footage, and requires the agency to surveil both live video and archived footage (stored for 60 days at the expense of the child care provider).
  • Requires immediate suspension of payments when fraud, waste, or abuse is “suspected,” before any investigation is complete. Specifies that any investigative records are not public records.
  • Creates a parent portal to report attendance directly to the state, bypassing providers and requiring a photo of the caretaker parent’s face every time. The bill specifies that records submitted to DCY through the portal are confidential and may only be used in accordance with the bill’s provisions.
  • Expands authority for the Attorney General to investigate and prosecute child care “fraud.”
  • Requirement that centers prove attendance and services at all times, or risk loss of funding and prosecution.

This bill would introduce constant state surveillance into Ohio child care centers, requiring providers to install and maintain cameras that record children and staff throughout the day, a level of monitoring that does not exist in any other state.

The bill does nothing to ensure that this sensitive content is transmitted or stored securely. It allows hundreds of hours of footage to be sent, received, and saved using systems with cybersecurity levels determined by individual programs’ internet connections.

The bill also forces providers to absorb the full cost of compliance of the video surveillance, including purchasing cameras, installation costs, maintaining storage systems capable of retaining 60 days of footage, and managing increased administrative responsibilities. These costs would come on top of existing staffing and operational pressures; as a result, some programs may reduce capacity or close entirely.

HB 649 gives the Department of Children and Youth broad authority to review or utilize all footage produced but provides no additional funding to meet those demands.

The bill allows the state to halt payments immediately based solely on suspicion of fraud, without any requirement for a completed investigation or due process. This would create acute financial instability for child care programs that already operate on razor‑thin margins.

Finally, the proposed parent portal raises significant concerns about accessibility and functionality. The bill requires caregiver parents, rather than providers, to record their child’s attendance through the new portal, though it does not clarify how families without smartphones or reliable internet access would comply, whether language access would be provided, or how corrections could be made, whether due to user error or software bugs. This is especially concerning given the state’s refusal to pay providers according to the industry standard: based on enrollment, not attendance. A parent running into trouble with the portal could mean lost income for a provider. HB 647 also makes it easier and faster to defund programs without due process, exposes data connected to Ohio’s kids, and reduces access to high-quality care.[6]

H.B. 647

Sponsored by Rep. Phil Plummer (R‑Dayton) and Rep. Tom Young (R‑Washington Twp.)

Key provisions

  • Funds enhanced automated data analytics, enabling state systems to conduct algorithmic attendance reviews across 5,200 child care centers serving over 100,000 children per day.
  • Allows DCY to immediately suspend licenses and provider agreements when fraud is suspected.
  • Establishes a framework for faster escalation of suspected fraud cases to the state auditor and Attorney General.
  • Authorizes the Ohio Attorney General to investigate and prosecute publicly funded child care programs suspected of fraud.
  • Removes language implementing enrollment-based payment by July 9, 2028.
  • Rescinds a provision that grants parents a waiver to be able to receive PFCC for more than one provider if “the child needs additional care during non-traditional hours.”
  • Removes $5 million from the Child Care Cred Program, Ohio’s version of Tri-share, (ALI 830414) to the Community Projects and Assistance Line Item (ALI 830420) for implementation, $2 million in FY 26 and $3 million in FY 27.

Concerns

This bill would dramatically increase state surveillance of child care provider data, adding intrusive oversight that does little to improve safety and exposes sensitive information to unnecessary risk. It provides no guardrails for protecting the trove of data, including personal information about providers, children, and parents, that would be gathered as a result of this bill.

The process to contract with an A.I. or tech company to conduct “enhanced automated data analytics” is unclear. The bill also does not address what kind of costs the state will incur on an initial or ongoing basis for this intrusion.

HB 647 will expand the power of the Attorney General to intervene in child care operations with no factual basis for doing so. The concentration of power in the Attorney General’s office is concerning because it would allow immediate license suspension and program closure based on simple suspicion of fraud — without any requirement for a full investigation, hearings, or standard due process.

The bill includes no threshold of validity or investigation of claims against child care programs. As we have all seen in the past weeks, suspicion of fraud is easily fabricated. Political fights using child care providers as pawns has already resulted in harm.[7] HB 647 would continue this trend, and risks leaving Ohio families suddenly without child care or recourse based on fabricated (or even openly prejudiced) claims.

HB 647’s proposed removal of language implementing enrollment-based payment by July 9, 2028, contradicts federal requirements. Those requirements may change, but until the new proposed federal rule rescinding elements of the 2024 CCDF Final Rule[8] is implemented, HB 647’s provisions are premature and put our federal funding for Ohio child care programs at risk.

Reducing options for workers will hurt families and the Ohio economy. Meeting these families’ and children’s needs is already difficult in a state with child care programs struggling to stay afloat and child care deserts growing.[9] By refusing to adequately fund PFCC, Ohio legislators already fail to address the needs of parents working second and third shift, weekends, or in the construction industry with common start times of 6 or 7 am.

In a state where legislators have allowed a child care crisis to fester for years, children, families, and providers deserve public policy that addresses real problems by increasing accessibility and funding. These bills would only make things worse.


[1] For reporting on these rumors, see the Columbus Dispatch’s December 31, 2025 report, Ohio day cares shielded from fraud by attendance system, DeWine says.

[2] See Policy Matters Ohio’s press release: Ohio’s child care oversight is transparent and effective.

[3] Read more about budget improvements that went largely unimplemented in Policy Matters Ohio’s August 1, 2024 report, How the Budget Can Bring Out the Best in Ohio.

[4] See Policy Matters Ohio’s February 20, 2025 report, Free Childcare for Childcare Workers is a better solution to Ohio’s childcare crisis.

[5] See the bill text here: https://www.legislature.ohio.gov/legislation/136/hb649

[6] See the bill text here: https://www.legislature.ohio.gov/legislation/136/hb647

[7] For reporting on harm caused by these divisive claims, see Axios’ January 7, 2026 report, Day cares face harassment as fraud claims reach Ohio.

[8] See Policy Matters Ohio’s January 16, 2026 Public Comment on Proposed Federal Rule “Restoring Flexibility in the Child Care and Development Fund (CCDF).

[9] See Policy Matters Ohio’s April 25, 2025 report, Ohio’s childcare crisis.

More Briefs

More Research

Get updates to your inbox.